{"key":"ma-fresh-4","idea":"Measure MA against B_RC on fresh paired seeds, stratified by first competitor spread; spread 1 measures P.","candidate_sha256":"5d1bd5272884f513b19f0e66a7c235f6c188a08e4f7787ac9346f1614dda3ed3","comparator_sha256":"02696ea6fd0922f64167a1153748f6a38bf2fd5d87c7a4ac6cb974bb9482f57c","seeds":{"start":921500,"end":921999},"n":500,"complete":true,"missing_seeds":[],"failures":[],"check_values":[{"seed":310000,"expected":17.512655,"observed":17.5126554022},{"seed":310001,"expected":24.258579,"observed":24.2585786274},{"seed":310002,"expected":2.390311,"observed":2.3903113616},{"seed":310003,"expected":249.541133,"observed":249.5411334743}],"python_version":"3.12.3","seconds_per_simulation":{"overall":{"candidate":1.0926735008759425,"comparator":1.0958049446893856},"by_spread":{"1":{"candidate":0.9582959478967964,"comparator":0.95449363619837},"2":{"candidate":1.0691905506738189,"comparator":1.0947308869603856},"3":{"candidate":1.1578524212079448,"comparator":1.135177536143197},"4":{"candidate":1.1870833179631899,"comparator":1.2028864541545856}}},"overall":{"n":500,"sum_d":-142.871795335,"sum_d2":12456.544439568977,"mean_diff":-0.28574359067,"se":0.22307488376460294,"comparator_mean":97.8849559592246,"retail_diff":-0.004229714613199225,"arb_diff":-0.28151387607},"by_spread":{"1":{"n":132,"sum_d":-13.795540983800173,"sum_d2":7049.04087664111,"mean_diff":-0.10451167411969828,"se":0.6384075018512348,"comparator_mean":41.149677078593186,"retail_diff":-0.8121700329674244,"arb_diff":0.7076583588727275},"2":{"n":113,"sum_d":-54.67900652269989,"sum_d2":4611.564053357769,"mean_diff":-0.4838850134752203,"se":0.6019029099068286,"comparator_mean":91.98552609652036,"retail_diff":0.5611914005557533,"arb_diff":-1.0450764140522124},"3":{"n":126,"sum_d":-74.39724782849994,"sum_d2":795.9395095700984,"mean_diff":-0.5904543478452376,"se":0.21851029994568175,"comparator_mean":116.29584621141905,"retail_diff":0.33076951414524036,"arb_diff":-0.9212238620500004},"4":{"n":129,"sum_d":0.0,"sum_d2":0.0,"mean_diff":0.0,"se":0.0,"comparator_mean":143.1246475480031,"retail_diff":0.0,"arb_diff":0.0}},"per_seed":[[921500,1,16.37461],[921501,3,0.096464],[921502,1,-4.029675],[921503,4,0.0],[921504,1,-0.215048],[921505,4,0.0],[921506,1,0.03238],[921507,2,-0.909748],[921508,3,-2.991153],[921509,3,-0.581224],[921510,1,-6.485095],[921511,1,0.569506],[921512,2,-0.111004],[921513,2,-4.799283],[921514,3,5.112944],[921515,2,-0.184319],[921516,1,0.004432],[921517,2,0.695607],[921518,3,-1.24139],[921519,4,0.0],[921520,3,0.3844],[921521,2,-6.521828],[921522,4,0.0],[921523,4,0.0],[921524,1,0.000717],[921525,2,0.904297],[921526,1,0.799477],[921527,4,0.0],[921528,2,-0.402165],[921529,1,2.902119],[921530,2,51.947984],[921531,3,-0.333561],[921532,3,-0.076024],[921533,2,1.494492],[921534,2,-2.436772],[921535,2,0.15921],[921536,3,1.565131],[921537,1,0.231308],[921538,2,0.544111],[921539,4,0.0],[921540,2,-0.158219],[921541,1,0.011671],[921542,2,-0.026111],[921543,3,-5.490149],[921544,1,2.431185],[921545,4,0.0],[921546,3,-2.739391],[921547,2,0.561782],[921548,1,-0.166653],[921549,2,0.134735],[921550,4,0.0],[921551,1,-3.742944],[921552,1,0.093439],[921553,4,0.0],[921554,1,0.097914],[921555,4,0.0],[921556,3,-0.16635],[921557,2,0.150436],[921558,3,-0.669904],[921559,1,0.40863],[921560,2,-0.389215],[921561,1,-0.181648],[921562,1,0.009529],[921563,3,-0.133637],[921564,3,-0.086267],[921565,4,0.0],[921566,1,0.011097],[921567,1,0.922001],[921568,2,-0.876824],[921569,3,0.079522],[921570,3,-1.668025],[921571,3,0.522619],[921572,1,-0.101901],[921573,3,0.34829],[921574,4,0.0],[921575,1,-0.000539],[921576,4,0.0],[921577,2,0.156641],[921578,4,0.0],[921579,1,-0.024503],[921580,4,0.0],[921581,3,0.00517],[921582,4,0.0],[921583,4,0.0],[921584,3,-0.077996],[921585,4,0.0],[921586,2,-0.279865],[921587,3,-0.473919],[921588,2,9.502071],[921589,1,0.355042],[921590,4,0.0],[921591,3,-2.375347],[921592,2,0.022013],[921593,1,0.008248],[921594,2,-2.623718],[921595,1,0.0],[921596,4,0.0],[921597,4,0.0],[921598,4,0.0],[921599,3,-3.160219],[921600,4,0.0],[921601,4,0.0],[921602,1,0.02206],[921603,3,-1.982159],[921604,2,3.114034],[921605,3,-0.872817],[921606,3,-0.157872],[921607,1,-0.008429],[921608,2,-0.6426],[921609,1,0.110111],[921610,1,0.0],[921611,4,0.0],[921612,4,0.0],[921613,1,-0.006139],[921614,3,-0.509282],[921615,2,-0.316366],[921616,3,-0.248087],[921617,2,1.006732],[921618,1,-0.062029],[921619,2,1.274924],[921620,4,0.0],[921621,3,0.589247],[921622,1,-0.527066],[921623,1,-44.565136],[921624,3,-0.080756],[921625,1,0.007477],[921626,1,-0.05794],[921627,1,0.003201],[921628,4,0.0],[921629,2,1.471848],[921630,4,0.0],[921631,1,0.004724],[921632,1,-10.672584],[921633,2,-0.039187],[921634,3,0.126343],[921635,1,-0.014074],[921636,4,0.0],[921637,3,-0.075543],[921638,2,-4.055121],[921639,3,-0.137637],[921640,3,-0.537634],[921641,4,0.0],[921642,3,0.146227],[921643,3,8.654648],[921644,2,-8.615542],[921645,2,0.035674],[921646,1,-0.017307],[921647,4,0.0],[921648,4,0.0],[921649,3,-0.435451],[921650,4,0.0],[921651,3,-0.214158],[921652,1,-0.894003],[921653,3,-0.099572],[921654,2,-0.482695],[921655,2,0.044322],[921656,3,-0.192912],[921657,3,4.775279],[921658,1,0.738109],[921659,1,1.219648],[921660,4,0.0],[921661,4,0.0],[921662,2,-2.537396],[921663,4,0.0],[921664,1,0.078903],[921665,4,0.0],[921666,4,0.0],[921667,4,0.0],[921668,2,-0.285841],[921669,1,-2.857022],[921670,2,-0.1127],[921671,2,-0.182059],[921672,2,-0.201171],[921673,1,0.00151],[921674,4,0.0],[921675,3,-4.194124],[921676,2,-0.515064],[921677,1,1.284105],[921678,4,0.0],[921679,2,0.212801],[921680,1,-7.572234],[921681,4,0.0],[921682,1,-0.026992],[921683,2,-2.000413],[921684,1,-1.111756],[921685,3,-1.934246],[921686,4,0.0],[921687,2,-2.501951],[921688,2,-0.341262],[921689,1,3.649813],[921690,3,-0.156917],[921691,4,0.0],[921692,1,-0.032468],[921693,1,2.229071],[921694,1,0.052005],[921695,3,-0.623162],[921696,1,-0.002108],[921697,1,9.697946],[921698,2,0.084995],[921699,3,-2.701344],[921700,1,-0.958344],[921701,1,-0.008713],[921702,3,0.581839],[921703,3,-0.2725],[921704,1,1.26526],[921705,4,0.0],[921706,2,-0.282038],[921707,1,0.000487],[921708,4,0.0],[921709,4,0.0],[921710,3,-0.557686],[921711,3,-1.379104],[921712,3,-0.961369],[921713,1,0.159842],[921714,4,0.0],[921715,1,0.088979],[921716,4,0.0],[921717,1,-0.896064],[921718,3,-0.471426],[921719,1,1.501001],[921720,3,0.137955],[921721,3,-0.133026],[921722,4,0.0],[921723,2,-1.204113],[921724,3,0.883425],[921725,4,0.0],[921726,3,-0.69375],[921727,2,0.127832],[921728,4,0.0],[921729,3,0.406024],[921730,2,6.28768],[921731,4,0.0],[921732,3,-0.235525],[921733,4,0.0],[921734,4,0.0],[921735,3,-0.303533],[921736,3,-8.627085],[921737,1,-0.464104],[921738,3,-1.441027],[921739,3,0.37052],[921740,1,0.000506],[921741,4,0.0],[921742,4,0.0],[921743,1,0.001501],[921744,4,0.0],[921745,1,0.072011],[921746,3,-0.481009],[921747,4,0.0],[921748,4,0.0],[921749,3,0.330981],[921750,4,0.0],[921751,4,0.0],[921752,2,-0.065187],[921753,4,0.0],[921754,4,0.0],[921755,3,0.640941],[921756,4,0.0],[921757,4,0.0],[921758,2,-0.321054],[921759,3,3.389739],[921760,2,0.16327],[921761,2,-0.031146],[921762,2,-2.187735],[921763,4,0.0],[921764,2,-1.1474],[921765,4,0.0],[921766,4,0.0],[921767,1,1.589469],[921768,4,0.0],[921769,2,0.261953],[921770,4,0.0],[921771,2,-0.160071],[921772,1,1.92577],[921773,1,-0.786509],[921774,3,-0.197035],[921775,4,0.0],[921776,4,0.0],[921777,1,-0.115663],[921778,3,-4.802137],[921779,2,0.032448],[921780,1,0.003536],[921781,2,-0.529555],[921782,3,-0.057571],[921783,3,-1.911151],[921784,1,5.085081],[921785,2,-0.113547],[921786,2,1.083063],[921787,2,0.274673],[921788,3,0.007128],[921789,1,0.0],[921790,4,0.0],[921791,1,0.019932],[921792,3,-0.088356],[921793,2,0.031306],[921794,4,0.0],[921795,4,0.0],[921796,3,-0.336942],[921797,3,-0.072962],[921798,2,-6.112988],[921799,4,0.0],[921800,3,-1.690028],[921801,3,-0.679345],[921802,3,-1.084343],[921803,1,0.015396],[921804,1,0.029871],[921805,4,0.0],[921806,2,-5.408548],[921807,4,0.0],[921808,3,4.912168],[921809,1,-0.37922],[921810,2,-0.365307],[921811,1,3.162469],[921812,4,0.0],[921813,4,0.0],[921814,4,0.0],[921815,3,0.095357],[921816,2,0.615647],[921817,1,-12.566018],[921818,1,0.0],[921819,2,-7.801025],[921820,4,0.0],[921821,2,-0.290289],[921822,4,0.0],[921823,3,0.289655],[921824,1,0.0],[921825,2,-10.08422],[921826,1,5.754731],[921827,3,-0.658422],[921828,2,-0.016877],[921829,4,0.0],[921830,4,0.0],[921831,2,-0.243715],[921832,2,-0.293179],[921833,4,0.0],[921834,3,-5.251796],[921835,3,-0.677608],[921836,1,0.050139],[921837,4,0.0],[921838,3,-4.123417],[921839,1,0.008843],[921840,4,0.0],[921841,2,-0.113173],[921842,2,-5.347825],[921843,4,0.0],[921844,1,-0.688192],[921845,3,-0.069521],[921846,4,0.0],[921847,4,0.0],[921848,2,-0.244231],[921849,1,-11.222732],[921850,1,-0.014605],[921851,2,-0.933258],[921852,4,0.0],[921853,2,-0.624227],[921854,3,-2.198654],[921855,3,-0.566819],[921856,4,0.0],[921857,1,-0.010895],[921858,2,-1.275883],[921859,1,61.13551],[921860,1,-0.057108],[921861,3,2.997611],[921862,3,-2.05551],[921863,2,0.430868],[921864,3,-0.769181],[921865,2,-0.188151],[921866,4,0.0],[921867,4,0.0],[921868,1,0.002391],[921869,3,-1.19267],[921870,3,-1.190793],[921871,4,0.0],[921872,2,0.016461],[921873,3,-1.829888],[921874,4,0.0],[921875,4,0.0],[921876,1,-1.691537],[921877,4,0.0],[921878,3,0.628428],[921879,2,-1.237882],[921880,3,-0.077163],[921881,4,0.0],[921882,3,4.125984],[921883,3,1.962833],[921884,1,0.621115],[921885,2,-1.576879],[921886,4,0.0],[921887,4,0.0],[921888,4,0.0],[921889,1,0.00586],[921890,2,-2.920582],[921891,1,-0.825747],[921892,2,-0.158007],[921893,3,-0.351126],[921894,2,-0.096024],[921895,2,-0.775182],[921896,1,0.001146],[921897,2,-0.861955],[921898,3,-0.425779],[921899,1,0.638588],[921900,3,0.007469],[921901,2,6.00172],[921902,4,0.0],[921903,2,-3.691037],[921904,1,-15.28592],[921905,3,-11.626057],[921906,2,-1.750662],[921907,4,0.0],[921908,1,2.914771],[921909,3,-2.971286],[921910,3,-4.346584],[921911,4,0.0],[921912,4,0.0],[921913,1,-0.848738],[921914,4,0.0],[921915,4,0.0],[921916,2,0.027862],[921917,4,0.0],[921918,1,-0.066264],[921919,1,-0.025587],[921920,1,0.07826],[921921,3,-0.610516],[921922,3,-5.543771],[921923,2,-4.007234],[921924,1,0.00612],[921925,4,0.0],[921926,2,-0.239586],[921927,1,-0.00088],[921928,2,3.425762],[921929,3,-1.344738],[921930,1,-0.019293],[921931,3,-3.837453],[921932,4,0.0],[921933,3,-1.349425],[921934,3,-5.593146],[921935,3,-0.249014],[921936,2,-0.634466],[921937,1,0.000109],[921938,3,-0.160351],[921939,1,-0.022768],[921940,2,-0.146876],[921941,1,0.051604],[921942,1,0.139028],[921943,4,0.0],[921944,1,-0.002714],[921945,1,0.016447],[921946,4,0.0],[921947,3,-0.455509],[921948,4,0.0],[921949,1,-0.006507],[921950,1,-1.604343],[921951,1,-0.051938],[921952,3,5.901871],[921953,2,0.029382],[921954,4,0.0],[921955,2,-3.767303],[921956,3,-0.59194],[921957,2,-0.335139],[921958,1,-0.059077],[921959,3,-0.237661],[921960,1,-5.305473],[921961,4,0.0],[921962,1,-0.492386],[921963,1,-4.153318],[921964,4,0.0],[921965,3,-0.154255],[921966,2,1.295713],[921967,3,-0.13119],[921968,2,-34.395576],[921969,1,0.681214],[921970,1,0.226855],[921971,4,0.0],[921972,2,0.130202],[921973,2,-0.306496],[921974,1,0.162023],[921975,4,0.0],[921976,3,-4.244],[921977,1,-2.797036],[921978,3,4.469228],[921979,2,0.038813],[921980,4,0.0],[921981,1,0.0],[921982,2,-0.228383],[921983,4,0.0],[921984,2,-3.15562],[921985,3,-1.761322],[921986,4,0.0],[921987,1,-0.784716],[921988,1,0.052838],[921989,2,-0.05067],[921990,3,1.856009],[921991,4,0.0],[921992,3,0.499977],[921993,2,-0.203628],[921994,3,-0.217796],[921995,4,0.0],[921996,3,-0.390566],[921997,4,0.0],[921998,1,-0.038523],[921999,3,-0.148604]],"worst_seeds":[{"seed":921623,"s":1,"d":-44.565136024,"candidate_edge":210.1343550042,"comparator_edge":254.6994910282},{"seed":921968,"s":2,"d":-34.395575925,"candidate_edge":-339.7001138052,"comparator_edge":-305.3045378802},{"seed":921904,"s":1,"d":-15.285920202500002,"candidate_edge":42.7388931013,"comparator_edge":58.0248133038},{"seed":921817,"s":1,"d":-12.566018289099986,"candidate_edge":384.8228584369,"comparator_edge":397.388876726},{"seed":921905,"s":3,"d":-11.62605688260004,"candidate_edge":346.1219362435,"comparator_edge":357.7479931261},{"seed":921849,"s":1,"d":-11.222732449300054,"candidate_edge":332.0415448075,"comparator_edge":343.2642772568},{"seed":921632,"s":1,"d":-10.672583698300002,"candidate_edge":-225.0312488525,"comparator_edge":-214.3586651542},{"seed":921825,"s":2,"d":-10.08421951630001,"candidate_edge":153.200197428,"comparator_edge":163.2844169443},{"seed":921736,"s":3,"d":-8.627085100299979,"candidate_edge":136.3624738114,"comparator_edge":144.9895589117},{"seed":921644,"s":2,"d":-8.615542252500006,"candidate_edge":117.4388499783,"comparator_edge":126.0543922308}],"off_target_zero":false,"notes":"Unmodified simulator b244530ee2a6247b5f930830eeca9dd950da0e7e; default config, 2000 steps; serial, unsandboxed, chunks of 50. All specified source hashes verified. No tuning; finalist seeds untouched. d uses engine total_edge with no additional rounding; only per_seed d rounded to 6 decimals. SE uses sample SD (ddof=1). Timing covers engine.run only. spread 1: B_RC wins; spread 2: B_RC wins; spread 3: B_RC wins; spread 4: tie"}